Home › Background Checks › What Records Appear › Criminal Records in Background Checks: What's Included and What Isn't
Background Checks

Criminal Records in Background Checks: What's Included and What Isn't

Not all criminal history shows up in every background check. Learn which records are typically surfaced, which are sealed, and why gaps exist.

Background Checks Editorial Team
9 min read · Jun 27, 2024
Criminal Records in Background Checks: What's Included and What Isn't

Photo: searchopenrecords editorial

—— In This Article
  1. What Criminal Records Typically Surface
  2. What Typically Does Not Appear
  3. Why Gaps Exist — and What They Mean
  4. How Check Type and Purpose Shape What's Visible

Key Takeaways

  • Felony and misdemeanor convictions are the most commonly surfaced criminal records in background checks.
  • Arrests without convictions may or may not appear, depending on jurisdiction and check type.
  • Sealed or expunged records are generally not visible, but gaps in database updates can cause exceptions.
  • No single background check searches every U.S. courthouse — geographic coverage always has limits.
  • Federal criminal records require a separate search from state and county-level databases.
  • FCRA rules restrict how non-conviction and older records can be reported in employment contexts.

What Criminal Records Typically Surface

The core of most criminal background checks consists of felony and misdemeanor convictions drawn from state court repositories, county courthouse records, and aggregated commercial databases. When a conviction is entered, the court typically sends that information to a state-level criminal history repository — such as a state bureau of investigation — which then becomes the primary source for many screening providers.

Beyond convictions, some checks also pull:

  • Pending charges — cases filed but not yet adjudicated
  • Arrest records — depending on state law and check type
  • Incarceration history — from department of corrections records
  • Sex offender registry data — sourced from state and national registries

The distinction between conviction and non-conviction records matters significantly. For employment-related checks governed by the FCRA, reporting agencies are restricted from including certain non-conviction information. For a detailed look at how sex offender registry data fits into this picture, see how registry data is gathered and where it falls short.

FCRA vs. Non-FCRA Background Checks

The Fair Credit Reporting Act governs background checks conducted by consumer reporting agencies for specific purposes such as employment, housing, and credit. Checks run directly by individuals through court websites or public records portals are not subject to FCRA restrictions, meaning different information may be accessible. Understanding which framework applies to your situation matters when evaluating what a report can legally contain. For more context on privacy boundaries, see our hub on privacy and limits in public records.

What Typically Does Not Appear

Several categories of criminal history are routinely absent from background check results — not because they don't exist, but because legal protections, database limitations, or jurisdictional gaps prevent their disclosure.

Sealed and Expunged Records

Courts can order that certain records be sealed or expunged, effectively removing them from public view. When properly processed, these records should not appear in FCRA-regulated reports. However, commercial data aggregators sometimes retain stale copies that haven't been updated after a court order. Our companion piece on how sealed records interact with background checks explores this lag in more depth.

Juvenile Records

Adjudications from juvenile court are almost universally protected by confidentiality statutes. In most states, they are not accessible through standard adult criminal background checks unless a juvenile was tried as an adult.

Dismissed Charges and Acquittals

Cases that were dismissed, declined for prosecution, or resulted in a not-guilty verdict generally should not be reported in employment-related screening. Whether they surface in non-FCRA contexts varies by state.

Out-of-Jurisdiction Offenses

If a check does not include the county or state where an offense occurred, that record will not appear — regardless of its severity. For a thorough explanation of how jurisdiction shapes coverage, see what each level of government captures.

Why Gaps Exist — and What They Mean

Even a well-structured background check is only as complete as its underlying data sources. Several structural factors create gaps:

  • Decentralized recordkeeping: The U.S. has no single national criminal database that is universally accessible. State and local courts manage their own records, and reporting timelines vary.
  • Database latency: Court entries often take days, weeks, or longer to propagate into commercial databases. Recent charges or dispositions may not yet be reflected.
  • Inconsistent state laws: What can legally be reported — and for how long — differs across states, meaning a check run in one state may surface records that another state's check would suppress.
  • Search scope decisions: Employers and screening companies choose which jurisdictions to search based on cost, time, and purpose. A national database search is faster but less thorough than a manual county-by-county courthouse pull.

These gaps matter in both directions. A person with legitimate history may not have it captured; conversely, an individual with a clean record may have an outdated entry incorrectly appearing. Understanding this is essential — as explored further in our article on why a clear background check result isn't always a complete picture.

Readers looking at the broader landscape of public record limitations may also find value in what public records actually leave out.

How Check Type and Purpose Shape What's Visible

Not all background checks search the same records or operate under the same rules. A check run by a licensed consumer reporting agency for employment purposes is regulated by the FCRA, which sets rules around accuracy, disclosure, and dispute rights. A check accessed directly through public court systems by an individual carries different constraints.

Similarly, the purpose of the check shapes its scope. Employment checks often focus on a seven-year window for non-conviction records; tenant screening may follow different state rules; licensing checks for professions like healthcare or law enforcement often go deeper and are subject to separate statutory frameworks.

For a structured overview of how different check types are assembled and what each covers, see how criminal, credit, and employment checks differ. If you're also curious about how financial records interact with background screening, our guide on financial records in background checks covers bankruptcies, liens, and judgments.

This article provides general educational information about public records and background checks. It is not legal advice. Readers with questions about their specific rights or record status should consult a qualified attorney.

Frequently Asked Questions

Arrests without a resulting conviction can appear in some background checks, particularly those that access raw court or law enforcement data. However, FCRA-regulated checks used for employment purposes often restrict or omit non-conviction records. The rules vary by state, so outcomes differ based on where the arrest occurred and what type of check is being run.
Expunged records are generally supposed to be hidden from background check results, but outdated or poorly updated commercial databases sometimes retain this data. The legal obligation to omit expunged records applies to FCRA-regulated reports, but private database aggregators may lag behind court updates. If you believe a sealed record is appearing incorrectly, you have the right to dispute it.
For FCRA-covered employment checks, non-conviction records are generally limited to seven years of lookback. Convictions, however, have no federally mandated time limit under the FCRA, though some states impose their own caps. Checks conducted outside the FCRA framework — such as for licensing or volunteer screening — may operate under different rules.
No. Federal criminal records are stored separately in U.S. District Court databases and require a dedicated federal court search. State-level offenses are held at the county or state repository level and must be searched jurisdiction by jurisdiction. Most standard background checks include at least one of these layers, but comprehensive coverage requires both.
Juvenile adjudications, records sealed by court order, charges that were dismissed or never filed, and offenses from jurisdictions not included in a database search are typically invisible. See our guide to records that almost never appear for a fuller breakdown.
Not necessarily. A clean result means nothing was found within the jurisdictions and databases that were searched — it is not a guarantee that no history exists. Database gaps, pending charges, and multi-state offenses can all affect completeness. Our article on why a clear result isn't always complete explains this in detail.
Background Checks Editorial Team

Background Checks Editorial Team

Background Checks Editorial Team is the collective byline for our editorial team and contributor network. Articles published under this byline or an editorial pen name are researched, written, and reviewed according to our editorial standards for clarity, consistency, and independence before publication.

View author profile
The content on this site is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional advice. Always consult a qualified professional for guidance specific to your situation.